This site may earn affiliate commissions from the links on this page. Terms of utilise.

Google is an advertising company that but happens to own a search engine and an operating organization. But the company is uncommonly sensitive to how its data-hoovering practices are discussed in the media. Earlier this calendar week, news broke that Porsche had chosen to use Apple's CarPlay rather than Android Car, due to the amount of data that Google gathers.

MotorTrend interviewed engineers at Porsche and reported the following: "As part of the agreement an automaker would accept to enter with Google, Porsche said sure pieces of data must be nerveless and transmitted back to Mountain View, California. Stuff like vehicle speed, throttle position, coolant and oil temp, engine revs—basically Google wants a complete OBD2 dump whenever someone activates Android Auto… Apple, by way of stark contrast, merely wants to know if the automobile is moving while Apple Play is in utilize."

Google, meanwhile, is pushing back against these claims. A spokesperson for the company told MotorTrend that it does not collect data on coolant temperatures or throttle position. The visitor declined to provide a list of exactly what it does gather. Instead, the spokesperson emphasized that using Android Auto is an "opt-in" characteristic, and that certain data is used for condom, like restricting typing and simply allowing voice input when the car is not in park. Other data is used to optimize the user's "app experience."

AndroidAutoChevyWithPhone

Yes, this comes downwards to a he-said / she-said state of affairs, but there are reasons to believe Porsche over Mountain View.

Google's abysmal privacy record

Outset, there's the fact that Google openly acknowledges just how much data information technology gathers. Equally far back as 2022, Sergey Brin told The Atlantic,"With your permission yous give u.s. more information about you, well-nigh your friends, and nosotros can improve the quality of our searches," he said. "We don't need yous to type at all. We know where y'all are. We know where you've been. We tin more or less now what you're thinking about." The company has been sued for numerous violations of user privacy across both the US and the Eu.

Android'south privacy policies give Google enormous power to gather and share data or to sell it in advertising, which is why devices like Amazon's Fire tablets and the Blackphone use custom Bone forks without Google Play or other Google services. The company has faced multiple lawsuits for various privacy-violating schemes and systems and has generally shown NSA-like restraint when it comes to vacuuming information off devices.

The fact that users accept to "opt-in" to share data with Android Auto is meaningless. The computing industry loves to talk about opt-in like it'south a separate checkbox or characteristic. In reality, Microsoft, Apple, and Google all regularly lock critical device features behind an "I Agree" button. If you want to utilise the capabilities of the Porsche, iPhone, or Surface you just purchased, you're going to have to agree (though Linux is at least hypothetically a possibility for a computer).

The he-said / she-said nature of this kind of argument almost certainly turns on the kind of subtle technicalities PR firms dearest to exploit. It's entirely possible that Porsche is telling the truth when it claims that Android Auto'due south license understanding gives Google the ability to rail big amounts of information, while Google could exist telling the truth when it says it doesn't currently runway specific types of information. Porsche is likely concerned about the kinds of information Google could requite itself permission to track if it chooses to do and so, and what its legal options are in the consequence Android Auto begins tracking data Porsche doesn't agree with.

The final reason I'thousand more inclined to concord with Porsche is that the automobile manufacturer has no reason to lie. It could have explained the situation past challenge that its own internal research found that its customers preferred Apple tree, or that it felt Apple tree's Machine Play was simply a amend fit for the kind of vehicle experience Porsche wanted to create. There are a hundred ways to explain the situation by emphasizing what makes Apple better as opposed to saying something negative about an Android service. Google, in contrast, has every reason to downplay the types of data Android Auto gathers, or tin gather.